Welfare for the Well Off? The progressivity of government transfers by income and wealth

Authors: Matthew Maltman, Matt Nolan and Ewan Rankin

Policy and demographics are changing the character of Australia’s social safety net. Cash transfers like JobSeeker and Family Tax Benefit are shrinking. Meanwhile, ‘in-kind’ transfers like government-subsidised education, disability and health care are increasing quickly.

This note uses survey microdata to detail how rising in-kind transfers are changing who receives government support. We find:

  • In-kind transfers are typically progressive. The lowest-income Australians receive 2 times more than the highest income Australians. But they are less progressive than cash transfers which have an equivalent ratio of 7 times. This is because cash transfers are more targeted to people with lower income and/or wealth.
  • There are substantial differences in progressivity by the type of in-kind transfer. Social housing is very progressive because it is a rare in-kind transfer with tight targeting on income and wealth. A contrasting example is child care subsidies, which are delivered roughly equally across the income distribution.
  • The NDIS – Australia’s fastest growing social protection program – is progressive, with the lowest-income households 3 times more likely to have a participant than the highest-income households.

In-kind transfers support people based on different concepts of need than cash transfers, and so progressivity is not the primary goal. For instance, the NDIS is designed to give Australians a universal ‘positive’ right to support if they face permanent disability. Even so, policymakers face a trade-off between universality – or the degree of targeting where it exists – and the rising fiscal cost of in-kind transfers which is putting pressure on Australia’s tax settings.

Related articles