South Australian state budget preview: SA’s chance to chart own fiscal destiny

budget61

 

Recent trends in South Australia’s net debt are not encouraging. But unlike Victoria, it has more room to move when it comes to finding a path to fiscal sustainability.


 

Since the late 1980s, South Australia and Victoria have seemed locked in the same fiscal and political cycle.

Both had State Bank failures and searing recessions in the early Nineties, then fiscal repair, privatisation and debt reduction under reformist Liberal Governments. Both swung to long-term centrist Labor administrations from the early 2000s, with popular Premiers and hard-nosed Treasurers running a model of low debt, modest service expansion and constrained capital works. Each had a one term minority Liberal government, then back to Labor.

More than any other two jurisdictions, Victoria and South Australia have been in fiscal and political lockstep.

Is this about to change? Tomorrow is South Australian Budget Day, and the key question is whether the State can decisively break from Victoria’s risky fiscal trajectory and chart a different course.

On the face of it, the recent trend in net debt is not encouraging. The headline pattern looks similar across the two states: low and stable debt for two decades, with a rapid ramp up since COVID. Victoria forecasts that its net debt will plateau at just under 25 per cent of Gross State Product (GSP) by 2030, 5 percentage points above South Australia’s. But SA’s widening cash deficit (as a percentage of GSP) implies net debt could keep rising beyond 2030.

Such is the scenario facing Treasurer Tom Koutsantonis. Tomorrow is his fifth Budget. The quirk is that its nine years since his last one.

Back then, in 2017, the Budget projected modest but steady operating surpluses, stable debt – at just over 5 per cent of Gross State Product – and an annual interest bill around 2 per cent of total spending.

Two Treasurers and one pandemic later, the Budget starting point looks different. Tomorrow’s Budget should again project modest operating surpluses over the forward estimates.  But net debt to GSP is now three times higher than in 2017 and interest costs will be pushing toward 6 per cent of total spending.

It’s a sobering context. And the Victorian and Tasmanian experience shows how quickly fiscal settings can deteriorate. For all that, there is a case for optimism.

Treasurer Koutsantonis has dismissed cost-of-living giveaways with refreshing candour, noting “it would be lovely to give everyone free public transport and free car parking, and a puppy.” As the Treasurer pointed out, public transport is already heavily subsidised. 

Unlike in Victoria and New South Wales, this is not a pre-election Budget. And the short gap between the recent SA election (March) and the early June Budget should help restrict new spending to election commitments only.

South Australia can also point to different drivers for its increased debt. Victoria accrued significant debt during COVID, to finance large operating deficits (and negative cash flow from recurrent/operating activities, before capital works). South Australia got through COVID and its aftermath with smaller operating deficits as a share of GSP.

The cumulative operating deficits between 2019-20 and 2024-25 added up to 6 per cent of annual GSP for New South Wales; 12 per cent for Victoria; but just 3.4 per cent for South Australia. Hence South Australians can take comfort that a larger share of the State’s increased debt is due to capital works, which in theory should add to the State’s balance sheet and net worth.

That said, other States have shown how hard it is to deliver such a large capital program with rigorous cost control. Particularly where complex mega-projects, like the Torrens to Darlington (T2D) motorway project, are concerned. Much will hinge on South Australia’s ability to manage these projects well.

Experience also shows that when a State takes on high risk mega-projects, it is all the more important to maintain strict control over recurrent spending growth, to protect against fiscal downside, if capital costs blow out. On this front, South Australia has some promising track record. Annual growth in employee expenses in the nine years to 2024-25 averaged 4.2 per cent in South Australia, compared with 7.6 per cent in Victoria – a larger gap than can be explained by differences in population growth.

Tomorrow’s Budget will include a fiscal target of keeping total expense growth below 4 per cent (roughly the growth in household incomes). The Budget Papers will claim this target has been met, by virtue of very low forecast future spending growth. The bigger question is whether actual spending growth will end up less than 4 per cent per year. One clue to this will be the spending growth figure for the 2025-26 year.

There are also risks on the revenue side. One such risk is stamp duty. Adelaide’s property market has been strong in recent years. Last December’s Mid Year Review forecast 5 per cent growth in stamp duty revenue for 2025-26 and a more moderate 3 per cent growth for 2026-27.

Tomorrow’s stamp duty revenue forecasts will be worth a look. Since December, the Reserve Bank has resumed its tightening cycle; and the changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax in the Federal Budget have contributed to property market pessimism, both about price growth and turnover, which together drive stamp duty receipts for State governments.

No state is immune to the revenue risk. But South Australia has one mitigating factor: along with Tasmania, it has less reliance on stamp duty, as a share of overall revenue, than other states.

South Australia’s conveyancing duty raises 5.3 per cent of total Budget revenue. Even royalty-rich Western Australia and Queensland have higher shares than that, with the big property states of Victoria and New South Wales higher still. New South Wales gets more than 10 per cent of its total revenue from stamp duty.

The risk of near-term weakness in stamp duty across the nation is real. But it will hit other States harder. If that happens, the revenue downgrades will eventually be offset by adjustments to state GST shares, but that will take time.

In dealing with future budget risks, South Australia has one other important source of flexibility: it is a relatively low tax jurisdiction. The Treasurer will want to keep it that way. But it’s a good starting point in case more revenue is needed at some stage.

One way to measure a State’s relative tax burden to compare how much revenue it raises, compared to the Commonwealth Grants Commission’s (CGC’s) estimate of ‘assessed’ revenue – the amount a State would collect if it applied average tax rates within its borders. Assessed revenue takes account of a State’s natural advantages and disadvantages. Mining states have higher assessed revenue from royalties, for example, reflecting natural endowments. Large states have higher assessed revenue from land tax, due to high property values in Sydney and Melbourne.

The ratio of actual to assessed revenue is around 100 for New South Wales, meaning it collects roughly the equivalent of what it should get with average tax rates. Victoria has a ratio of 112, indicating that it taxes its available bases heavily.

South Australia has a ratio of 94.3. It raises $231 per person less than it would with average tax rates. Victoria raises $597 per person more. In the event of fiscal difficulty, an already high-taxing state could struggle to eke out extra revenue. South Australia has more scope.

As a small jurisdiction with a narrow economic base, there is good reason for South Australia to maintain tax competitiveness against its larger east coast neighbours. But the State’s low tax status gives it flexibility – for future fiscal repair, or for tax reform.

One area for future reform is payroll tax. Since 2019, South Australia has had a distinctively inefficient payroll tax system. In that year, the then Government raised the tax-free threshold from $600,000 to $1.5 million (of firm payroll), but strangely, left the ‘deductible’ amount at $600,000. That means firms only pay tax once their payroll crosses the $1.5 million threshold, but when they do, they pay tax on every dollar in excess of $600,000. This is a unique disconnect. Every other state aligns the threshold with the deductible amount.

The result is a system in which firms with payroll below $1.5 million pay no payroll tax, while firms between $1.5 million and $1.7 million pay an effective marginal rate above 25 per cent for each extra dollar of payroll. Those with payrolls above $1.7 million pay a 4.95 per cent tax on the amount of payroll in excess of $600,000.

Previous e61 research has indicated that many firms, predictably enough, maintain a payroll just under $1.5 million, avoiding the steep marginal rates immediately above that figure. Some of these firms had been steadily growing before the policy change, then stopped growing as they approached the new threshold. Others actually reduced their payroll to get below the threshold. The policy is a brake on firm growth and likely on overall productivity. At some point, a useful reform would be to reduce the threshold and smooth the marginal rate above it, thus removing the barrier to growth and potentially raising more revenue overall.

There are worse ways for a State to raise tax revenue than a flatter, low-rate payroll tax. And according to the CGC, South Australia has the lowest ratio of actual to assessed payroll tax revenue of any State, raising $128 less per person than it would if it applied the average policy.

Tomorrow will not be the day for that sort of reform. Hopefully there will be scope in future Budgets for that. Rather, we can expect the funding of election commitments, modest projected operating surpluses and hopefully a low spending growth figure for 2025-26 and 2026-27. Ideally, there will be some planned moderation in the capital spend and a lessening of cash deficits by the end of the forward estimates.

This would all help break the long-standing, synchronised fiscal and political cycle shared by South Australia and Victoria for the better part of four decades. That would be an historic achievement. Despite rising debt and interest payments, and large, complex capital projects, tomorrow’s Budget presents an opportunity for South Australia to chart a different course.

Which means spending restraint with few giveaways like free or cheap transport. And no puppies.


Michael Brennan

Michael Brennan is the CEO of the e61 Institute. He is an experienced economic policy professional, having been a former Chair of the Australian Productivity Commission and Deputy Secretary of the Australian Treasury. He has also worked as a Deputy Secretary in the Victorian Treasury, and as a consultant as well as an adviser to Federal and State Treasurers and Ministers for Finance.