Science degrees but not science careers? 

plus61

Natural science degrees often don’t lead to STEM careers, raising concerns for women’s participation in STEM and the future STEM workforce.

Stay updated with the latest news and subscribe to our Newsletter

In the week leading up to Christmas, high school graduates across the country received their Australian Tertiary Admission Rank (ATAR). Since then, those interested in pursuing further study will have finalised their university degree preferences and begun accepting initial offers. This decision of what to study at university attracts a great deal of attention and could potentially influence their careers for years to come. 

But while the value of choosing an arts or humanities degree is perennially debated, one assumption tends to be uncontested: that a STEM degree is a safe bet.  

What if this isn’t quite right? What if, when it comes to career outcomes, not all STEM fields were created equal?  

In forthcoming e61 research, we looked at career outcomes for graduates in STEM fields using administrative data from Australian universities linked to de-identified tax returns. What we found was that outcomes for graduates in the natural sciences (e.g. biology, chemistry, physics and earth sciences) were very different from those in other STEM fields.  

Most strikingly, natural science graduates were much less likely to get a job as a professional in their field. 

In fact, just 8 per cent of natural science graduates were working as a natural science professional or manager within two years of graduating. By contrast, 51 per cent of engineering graduates and 42 per cent of IT graduates went on to work as professionals in their respective fields within two years. These trends are present even among the highest ATAR students, where the disparity is even larger. And they are not short-lived with this difference persisting even when we look at outcomes 6 years after graduation.

So, what were the other 92 per cent of natural science graduates doing?  

A few found jobs as professionals in other fields.  

Besides the 8 per cent working as natural science professionals, around 22 per cent were working in a role that required a university education – but three quarters of these jobs were completely outside of STEM. While a larger share of natural science graduates were working as a professional within 6 years of graduating, the share working in STEM fields remained very low. 

The remaining natural science graduates who didn’t land a job as a professional tended to fall into two categories, depending on their ATAR. 

  1. Overqualification of lower ATAR graduates. More than 44 per cent of natural science graduates with an ATAR of 70 or below were working in a role that did not require a degree. This overqualification remained substantial even 6 years after graduation.  
  1. A path to medical school for higher ATAR graduates. Around 34 per cent of natural science graduates with an ATAR of 95 to 100 returned to full-time university study. For many, a natural science degree appears to be a launching pad for a career in medicine, with 21 per cent of this high-achieving cohort going on to complete a medical degree and enter the workforce as a medical professional. 

Why does it matter that natural science degrees generally don’t lead to STEM careers? And why should policymakers care? 

First, the natural sciences currently account for half of all undergraduate STEM degree commencements in Australia’s universities. Moreover, while STEM degree commencements have grown from nearly 40,000 in 2005 to over 65,000 in 2020, most of that growth has been absorbed by the natural sciences.  

Second, the low share of natural science graduates that find work in STEM fields poses a challenge for efforts to get more women into STEM occupations.  

Between 2005 and 2016, only 15 per cent of women who commenced a bachelor’s degree did so in a STEM field, compared to 36 per cent of men.  

Among women who did enrol in a STEM degree, 80 per cent studied a degree in the natural sciences, while only 40 per cent of male STEM students did so.  

And while just 20 per cent of male natural science graduates were working in STEM 6 years after graduating, an even smaller (14 per cent) share of female natural science students were doing the same. 

Taken together, this means the promising enrolment and completion numbers for women in the natural sciences masks the severity of the gender gap in STEM when it comes to career outcomes. 

So, what should policymakers do?  

The natural sciences dominate as the degree of choice for STEM students, particularly for women. But because most natural science graduates do not go on to work in STEM, much of the recent growth in STEM enrolments is not translating into what really matters: a larger STEM workforce.  

At the same time, demand for engineers and IT professionals is only set to rise in the era of AI, automation, and the clean energy transition.  

Instead of trying to attract more students into STEM overall, perhaps policymakers should consider encouraging more would-be natural science students to enter a degree that more reliably leads to a career in STEM, such as engineering or IT. Then again, this all could point to the limitations of an approach that privileges some fields of study over others.