It’s a match! Why we should care about who partners with whom 

plus61

How assortative mating is reshaping inequality and the geography of housing demand.

Stay updated with the latest news and subscribe to our Newsletter

Ahead of Valentine’s Day, it’s worth remembering what Jane Austen once famously wrote in the opening line of Pride and Prejudice:

“It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife.”

Austen was mocking the marriage market of Regency England where a single man’s worth was measured by his income. Modern economic research suggests that it is no longer just the men being judged on their economic credentials. Increasingly, if you are in possession of a good fortune, you are also in want of someone who possesses the same.

This tendency for people to partner with people that have similar economic characteristics as themselves is known as assortative mating. Evidence from around the developed world suggests that it is on the rise, with sorting based on income, education and wealth common.

Similar patterns are emerging in Australia. Couples where both partners hold a university degree are now the most common household type among working-age adults.

This partly reflects the increasing educational attainment of women. But even after taking that into account, people with a university education are still much more likely to wind up with another university-educated person than if they partnered at random.

From our analysis of 2021 Census data, we find that people with a bachelor’s degree are approximately 85 per cent more likely to be partnered with someone who also has a bachelor’s degree than if people were matched randomly.

Because higher levels of education are related to higher levels of lifetime income, this means that when people with bachelor’s degrees partner up they also tend to combine higher levels of income.

This may all sound like a sociological curiosity, but the increase in assortative mating has two important economic consequences.

The first consequence is that it amplifies inequality.

When high earners partner up with high earners, and low earners with low earners, income becomes further concentrated at the top of the distribution. 

The effect on inequality is large. Evidence from the US suggests that the Gini Coefficient for household income inequality would have fallen from 0.43 to 0.34 in 2005 (where 0 is perfect equality, and 1 perfect inequality), if people had partnered at random rather than sorting based on income. This is equivalent to moving from US levels of inequality to those seen in Spain.

Assortative mating also doesn’t just widen inequality today; it strengthens the persistence of economic status across generations. High-income couples can more easily buy into in higher-opportunity neighbourhoods, support longer periods of study for their children and provide financial assistance and insurance to them in adulthood. These factors are all important determinants of a child’s future success.

The second consequence of assortative mating is that it shapes where people want to live.

When both partners in a household work, they face a problem: they need to live somewhere that provides suitable employment opportunities for both.

This “two-body problem” becomes more challenging when partners have highly paid, highly specialised careers. Such job opportunities are fewer and farther between, limiting where couples can live while both finding suitable work.

For many, the solution is simple: move to a major city. Large cities don’t just offer higher wages, they also offer a much wider range of job opportunities. This increases the chance that both partners can find work, and if one needs to change jobs, they can do so without uprooting the entire family.

It’s no surprise then that in Australia, households where both partners are highly educated are the most urbanised of groups. Once two careers are established in the same place, households tend to stay. Over time this can concentrate housing demand.

What does this mean for policy?  

Who partners with whom is nobody’s business, least of all policy makers. But the rise of assortative mating highlights how economic pressures can emerge from how households form.

Two of these pressures are increasingly relevant to policy. First, when high earners pair up, their economic advantages combine rather than spread out. Housing access, schooling options, and financial resilience all depend on a household’s combined income, so it matters to policymakers if inequality between families is rising due to assortative mating.

Second, dual-income households increasingly need access to “thick”, diverse job markets. The interaction between changes in household formation and where jobs are located contributes to the concentration of housing demand in major cities.

Addressing the pressures created by this requires thinking about both where people live and where work can be done. Reforms to boost housing supply could allow more people to live in high-demand locations closer to jobs. Better transport links and remote-work options could allow people to access more job opportunities from where they live.

Ultimately, as Valentine’s Day draws near it’s worth remembering that these aren’t just abstract policy points. Pride and Prejudice is a story of the value of personal merit over wealth and status. But increasingly, the well-off Mr Darcys of today are marrying the also well-off Caroline Bingleys, not the less well-off Elizabeth Bennetts – and the consequences for inequality and housing demand are anything but fictional.

Tiya Banerjee

Tiya is a Pre-doctorate Economist at the e61 Institute. She holds a Bachelor of Economics and a Bachelor of Advanced Studies (Honours in Economics) from the University of Sydney.

Elyse Dwyer

Elyse is a Senior Research Economist at the e61 Institute. Her research areas cover structural reform, labour markets, education and housing. Elyse holds a University Medal and First Class Honours in Economics from the University of Queensland.