It was a big budget so it’s understandable some critical details were lost in the noise. e61’s experts are here with the lowdown on the stories not to be missed.
Reporting and public debate about the Albanese Government’s fifth Budget has focused on sweeping changes to capital gains tax, negative gearing and tax rates on trusts, as well as Labor’s claim to be easing the future burden on younger workers.
But beneath headlines about broken election promises and a brewing intergenerational tussle, the Budget contains important details that have received too little attention. Here, e61’s experts unpack five aspects that have largely flown under the radar – three stories buried within the headline themes of tax, housing and the NDIS, and two that stand out for their absence: JobSeeker and action on illicit tobacco.
1. A vision for a new tax system emerges
By Matt Nolan
At face value, the Budget’s personal and business tax changes seem unrelated. Some support business investment, while others increase taxes on those who earn high returns on their savings. Some redirect investor demand toward new housing, while others attempt to ease cost-of-living pressures through tax cuts.
But look more closely and a common principle emerges – that a fair and efficient tax system should ask people in similar economic circumstances to contribute in similar ways, while also reducing tax distortions to work, saving and investment.
This is a coherent vision for the tax system, and if followed through to its logical conclusion it would lead to further, critical tax reform.
Replacing the CGT discount with indexation moves the system closer to taxing real capital gains like labour earnings, rather than arbitrarily favouring some gains over others. Minimum tax rates on capital gains and trusts reduce the ability of some taxpayers to use timing or structures to access very low tax rates. Loss carry-backs, start-up refundability, the permanent instant asset write-off, and better-targeted R&D support move business taxation closer to a system where investment choices are less distorted by the timing and risk of tax deductions.
Of course, a single budget can only do so much. Genuinely embedding the principles embodied by these measures in the tax system would require a sustained reform program over coming years. But the fact there is a discernible thread running through these measures suggests they may be part of a more coherent agenda, rather than a one-off grab bag of changes.
That agenda would be a substantial one. Taxing real income consistently means dealing with inflation across the whole system: income tax thresholds, saving income, interest deductions and losses.
It also means dealing with the lumpy nature of capital gains – a concern that current tax settings do not deal with. To tax capital gains like labour income, the liability should be assessed as if the gain were earned across the period the asset was held.
For example, someone earning $80,000 a year in wages who receives a $1 million real capital gain after 10 years has the same decade-long real income as someone earning $180,000 a year. Under indexation this individual will pay a tax rate of 35 per cent, compared to the 29 per cent paid by someone who earns $180,000 a year from wages and salaries. Without income averaging, inflation indexation alone can result in taxes on lumpy capital income that are far higher than taxes on equivalent wages.

On the business side, the package hints at a broader move toward cash-flow taxation, or at least toward taxing supernormal returns without penalising marginal investment.
Loss-refundability achieves this by making the treatment of losses and gains more symmetric in the tax system. An instant asset write-off matches the timing of when the cost of investment occurs for businesses and when it is recognised for tax. By allowing these timing changes, firm revenue and costs are recognised by the tax system when they occur, improving the cash flow position of young growing firms when they invest. The next challenge is making that organising principle explicit across the taxation of businesses.
Overall, the tax reform in this Budget was principled and brave. But it also reflects only a first step towards a more coherent vision for future taxation in Australia.
2. Three reasons the NDIS save deserves more attention
By Pelin Akyol
The single biggest measure in the Budget was the $37.8 billion in NDIS savings projected over the next four years. Three aspects of this reform deserve closer attention than they’ve received.
The first is the sheer scale of the save and the policy challenge of delivering it. For all the post-Budget noise about tax, the NDIS reforms have drawn remarkably little attention given their fiscal weight. As e61 CEO Michael Brennan noted on Friday, no other Budget has ever been so dominated by a single program saving – a saving that carries the weight of a government’s entire fiscal strategy. The $37.8 billion contribution dwarfs the combined yield from changes to trusts, capital gains tax and negative gearing. And unlike most Budget saves, it can’t be delivered by the stroke of a pen.
The second is a point we’ve made before. Eligibility and plan-size changes can only do so much to control the long-term cost growth of the NDIS. Even if the reforms are successful, the NDIS will remain a $55 billion program and one of the fastest-growing in the federal Budget. The largely untouched lever for controlling that growth is market structure. The NDIS isn’t a conventional welfare program but a market for services, and that market isn’t working as intended.
The risk is particularly acute at the high-intensity end. Supported Independent Living accounts for $16.2 billion in spending, and new registration and commissioning rules from July 2026 are likely to shift provision toward larger providers and weaken already-thin competition. Reforms that change who can provide services, without fixing the underlying market design, may risk consolidating provision in ways that make cost control harder, not easier, over the longer term.
The third aspect is more subtle. The measures announced in the Budget overlap on the same participants, raising questions about both the distribution of impacts and how the savings have been forecast.
Intellectual disability, autism and psychosocial disability participants account for 66.5 per cent of Core Community Participation spending ($7.6 billion of $11.5 billion) and 93.9 per cent of Social & Civic Participation – the key budget items the reforms are targeting. These same groups are the cohorts most likely to be exposed to tighter eligibility via functional capacity assessments from 2028.
Because the reforms are phased in sequentially, with community participation resets from October 2026, and eligibility tightening from January 2028, the effects on this group are likely to compound. The degree to which these compounding effects have been factored into the headline $37.8 billion savings estimate is not clear from the Budget Papers.

Taken together, these three points suggest the challenge ahead is bigger than the headline number lets on. The save is large, but the lever is limited, the impact is concentrated, and implementation risks are significant. None of that means the reforms are doomed to fail, but it does mean that implementation and market design will matter as much as the headline savings figure itself.
3. Changes to negative gearing not a huge deal for investors
By Nick Garvin
Much of the commentary around the changes to negative gearing has overlooked the nuances that will determine how they’ll affect the housing market.
Currently, about half of all housing investors are “negatively geared”, which means that they have a net rental income loss. Under the current tax system, these losses can be claimed as a tax deduction against other income in the same year. The reforms announced in the Budget mean this will no longer be possible (for purchases other than new builds).
However, investors will still be able to claim these losses as tax deductions, just from future taxable capital gains (see Box 4.3 in Budget Paper 1). The timing of deductions will change but the end result is similar.
This change to negative gearing would be more significant if the budget did not also replace the 50 per cent CGT discount with inflation indexing. Previously, the CGT discount halved investors’ tax rate on gains, which also reduced the value of deductions. With inflation indexing, investors can claim the full value of those deductions.
This means that the main effect of the negative gearing changes on investor returns will be through cashflow timing. For most investors, tax deductions will be a similar amount but delayed to sale time when CGT is paid. Of course, there is also an inflation cost, as later tax deductions are worth less due to inflation eroding their values. This inflation effect may end up being the most consequential part of the reform for investors.
The changes will make some investors better off. As noted by Matt Nolan above, middle-income investors are often pushed into higher tax brackets when they sell. For them, delaying deductions until sale could reduce their total tax paid. On the flip side, investors whose property prices fall are likely to be worse off because they have no capital income to deduct the rental losses from.
Perhaps more importantly, the housing tax reforms reduce the asymmetry that incentivises excessive leverage. There are better ways to achieve this, but it’s an improvement. The tax rate on capital gains and the tax deduction rate on rental income losses will now essentially be the same.
The result is likely to be a small reduction in average after-tax returns, with some winners and some losers – we will know more once we test the numbers.
4. A shift from jobseekers to workers
By Elyse Dwyer
As seasoned budget-watchers know, sometimes the most telling measures are the ones that aren’t there. One of the big omissions from this year’s Budget was the JobSeeker Payment (JSP), which barely rated a mention. Commonwealth Rent Assistance was also largely absent, despite housing costs being a headline theme. Both omissions stand out at a time when much of the focus is on cost-of-living pressures.
This marks a big shift from the politics of cost-of-living relief only a few years ago. In 2022, when petrol prices spiked following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the previous Government’s response included a one-off $250 payment to eligible welfare recipients. It was billed as temporary, targeted and explicitly aimed at cushioning the impact for those most exposed to the shock.
This Budget speaks to a different constituency. Some of its headline measures included the Working Australians Tax Offset (WATO), a $250 tax cut for more than 13 million workers, as well as the $1,000 instant deduction available for work-related expenses. These weren’t billed as a cost-of-living support measures – they instead sit in a tax reform statement. But the emphasis is telling. The Government is now talking less about cushioning people outside the labour market, and more about rewarding those in it.
This shift will leave a gap. While the WATO will improve the finances of many households as inflationary pressures mount, it will not reach those with little or no earnings. Previous e61 research has shown that the people who face the most acute financial pressure from inflation are low-income households.
The JSP is indexed to CPI inflation, but there are lags in how much relief that indexation can provide during a rapid inflation surge. Earlier e61 work has shown that petrol spending consumes a larger share of income for poorer households. This difference in spending widened sharply after the 2022 shock, and it’s likely that the current shock is also hitting low-income households in much the same way.

A few years ago, a global oil shock prompted targeted support for those most exposed. With another oil shock under way, the Government has chosen a different path – one that places working households, rather than the lowest-income households, at the centre of its relief efforts.
5. The ongoing collapse of tobacco revenue
By Lachlan Vass
One revenue trend which flew under the radar on Tuesday was the continuing decline in tobacco excise and its implications for one of Labor’s previously hard-fought preventative health measures.
Historically, the tobacco excise has been the Federal Government’s leading lever to address smoking rates. The excise is intended to dampen demand for cigarettes through increasing their cost.
However, recent budget updates have seen significant downgrades in tobacco excise revenue, which has fallen from around $12 billion before COVID to $7.8 billion in 2024-25. This trend continued, with last week’s Budget expecting $13.7 billion less tobacco revenue than the previous Budget and estimating revenue to be as low as $2.1 billion by 2029-30.
It’s worth saying that again. The Government is now expecting to go from collecting around $12 billion a year in tobacco excise to $2 billion. Around $10 billion dollars a year up in smoke in just 10 years.

This would be welcome news if it reflected fewer people smoking – that’s what the tobacco excise policy is meant to do. However, much of the decrease is due to the rise of the illicit tobacco market, whose market share is estimated by the Government to have increased from 8 per cent in 2018-19 to up to 60 per cent in 2024-25.
Another downgrade in expected tobacco revenue suggests this problem will continue to get worse. The Government’s forecasts imply, if overall market size doesn’t change, that the illicit market could account for over 80 per cent of the total market by 2029-30.
The Budget was largely silent on the Government’s strategy from here, allocating only $14 million of new funding to the illicit tobacco fight. This is in addition to previous commitments of over $300 million for increased enforcement and compliance. However, these commitments remain relatively small compared to both the gains on offer to criminal actors and the $10 billion in potential annual revenue the Government is now expecting to lose.
Part of the problem could be an incentive mismatch – while the Federal Government benefits from improvements in enforcement through higher excise, state governments are the ones largely responsible for enforcement on the ground and incur the direct cost.
There’s also a hesitation among some to give ‘big tobacco’ a win by lowering the excise, or to encourage smoking through a lower excise. However, the counterfactual matters. The current situation provides a win to criminal organisations and exposes smokers to lower prices in the illicit market, incentivising them to smoke more. The Budget forecasts set out the scale of the problem in stark detail. What the Budget didn’t set out is a plan. Until one arrives, the status quo continues to deliver a steady win to criminal organisations and cheaper cigarettes to most smokers, the opposite of what the excise was designed to do.

Pelin Akyol
Pelin Akyol is an applied economist whose research spans education, labour markets, health, and demographics. She uses both structural and reduced-form methods to study how people make decisions about education and work, and how those decisions shape social outcomes, particularly across gender and demographic lines. Her work has been published in leading economics journals and featured in VoxEU and EducationWeek. Pelin holds a Ph.D. in Economics from Penn State University.

Elyse Dwyer
Elyse is a Senior Research Economist at the e61 Institute. Her research areas cover structural reform, labour markets, education and housing. Elyse holds a University Medal and First Class Honours in Economics from the University of Queensland.

Nick Garvin
Nick specialises in microdata research for economic and financial-system policy. He has 15 years of research experience at e61, RBA and APRA on topics related to housing, mobility, superannuation, financial stability, financial markets, and payments, and has been an econometrics lecturer at UNSW. Nick holds a PhD in Economics from Pompeu Fabra University, a Masters in Economics from London School of Economics, and Bachelor Degrees in Economics and Psychology from Macquarie University.

Matt Nolan
Matt is a Senior Research Manager at the e61 Institute. His research is focused on analysing income distributions using microdata, with a focus on how taxes, transfers, and changes in labour market settings influence the distribution of income. Matt previously worked at the Inland Revenue Department of New Zealand and as a teaching fellow at Victoria University of Wellington. He holds a PhD in Philosophy (Economics) from Victoria University of Wellington.

Lachlan Vass
Lachlan is a Research Manager at the e61 Institute. He is a former Treasury official and regular media commentator on the Budget. Lachlan leads work at the intersection of economics, data, and public policy, with a current focus on immigration, productivity, and firm dynamics. Lachlan holds a Honours in Economics from the University of Melbourne. He is currently undertaking a PhD (Economics) at the Australian National University.