Complex minimum wages may work to our advantage

plus61

New overseas research offers to reconcile that both positive and negative employment effects are possible from minimum wage increases.

Stay updated with the latest news and subscribe to our Newsletter

Tuesday next week, the Fair Work Commission (FWC) will decide on an increase in minimum wages that directly affects 3 million Australian workers, and perhaps 3 million more indirectly. Public discussion has focused on how higher minimum wages would relate to trends in productivity and affect inflation. There has been little debate of how increased minimum wages might or might not reduce employment. 

This is surprising. The potential for employment effects is explicitly referenced in the FWC’s legislated objectives and has been a popular research topic among economists. Still, the Australian Government’s submission to the FWC review makes no mention of it. Only deep in submissions from the ACTU and business groups can you find a direct discussion. 

The challenge with evaluating employment effects is that economists disagree on the evidence and theory.  

One theoretical view is that higher minimum wages price marginal workers out of the labour market, reducing employment.  

A contrasting theoretical view is that higher minimum wages need not cause lower employment because firms have monopsony power – that is, they are a powerful buyer of labour facing limited competition. These firms suppress wages and employment. An appropriate minimum wage breaks that equilibrium and can drive higher employment alongside higher wages. 

There have been hundreds of empirical studies internationally to test these theories, but economists disagree on the weight of evidence.  

Some say there is a clear majority pointing to some negative employment effect, especially for young and less-educated workers. 

Others say that increases in minimum wages usually have little effect on employment.  In Australia, recent evidence gives a similar sanguine picture.   

Two recent pieces of frontier economic research – ‘Minimum Wages, Efficiency and Welfare’ and ‘The Macroeconomic Dynamics of Labour Market Policies’ – give hope of a synthesising framework.  

Within this framework, higher minimum wages generally promote equity but can have positive or negative employment effects depending on the minimum wage level and time period considered. Here are three key points: 

  • At lower levels of minimum wages, increases directly benefit lower-income workers by raising wages and even employment (if there is employer monopsony). But beyond some threshold, further increases can overcook it relative to the productivity of the most marginal workers and cause lower employment. 
  • Because there are many different firms and workers, there is no single perfect minimum wage to offset monopsony across the economy. Inevitably, a minimum wage that is a good fit for one group is a bad fit for another group. 
  • Most empirical studies of minimum wage changes focus on relatively short-term effects. This new framework suggests that long-run employment effects could be negative, even if short-term effects are not. Firms have more opportunity to adjust their business models in the long run. 

Australia’s system of award wages are, on average, the highest minimum wages in the developed world. In the latest cross-country data for 2022, only Costa Rica and Colombia – less comparable middle-income economies – had higher minimum wages in the OECD. Also shown is Australia’s National Minimum Wage (NMW), which is effectively the lower bound on award wages and is received by few workers in practice.

Should we be worried about negative employment effects, especially in the long run? Not necessarily. This is because the complexity of Australia’s award wage system can work to its advantage.  

There are more than 100 awards, each with a series of wage levels differentiated across occupations, experience and work capacity. This permits the relevant minimum wage to vary between lower and higher productivity roles, in principle at least. If, instead, there were a single minimum wage set at the average rate of awards, it would be much more likely to price out jobs in lower-skill roles. 

Policymakers also need to be mindful that economic trends can differ materially among award-reliant industries.  

There are 5 market-sector industries where more than a quarter of employees rely on awards: hospitality, administration & support, retail, arts & recreation and other services. Among those industries, decade average labour productivity growth has ranged from 0.5 up to 1.9 per cent per year. 

And yet all award wages are generally adjusted up by the same amount each year. The Fair Work Commission does occasionally review and adjust specific awards, as it did following a recent review of gender undervaluation. But this is still a relatively rigid system.  

Given Australia’s high, complex and rigid minimum wages, the FWC should remain mindful of the risk of negative employment effects. Australia may be a tough setting to conduct empirical analysis on the topic. But careful monitoring is still warranted, especially at times when large increases are delivered and within industries that are experiencing below-average productivity growth. Australia’s labour market has performed remarkably well in recent times. But the latest economic research highlights that the effects of minimum wage increases can unfold over long time frames.